Is Air Conditioning Cheaper Than Gas Heating?

As energy prices continue to rise and concerns about sustainability grow, many Sydney homeowners are weighing the costs and benefits of air conditioning versus gas heating. With temperatures fluctuating and energy bills on the rise, which option is right for you—one that provides comfort, saves on energy bills, and aligns with your environmental goals?

In this article, we’ll break down the costs, efficiency, and environmental impact of air conditioning and gas heating, highlighting the latest technological advancements that make air conditioning a strong contender for year-round climate control. We’ll also explore the environmental implications of each, helping you decide which option best fits your budget and sustainability goals in New South Wales.  

‍

‍

Understanding the Systems

In Australia, two popular home heating systems often come into play: reverse cycle air conditioning and gas heating. Each system offers unique benefits, so it's essential to understand their differences to choose the best option for your home.

‍

What Is Reverse Cycle Air Conditioning?

Reverse cycle air conditioning works by extracting heat from the outside air and transferring it inside. The system uses refrigerant to absorb heat, compress it to raise its temperature, and then circulate warm air throughout your home.

How Reverse Cycle AC Works for Heating

• Heating Mode: The system extracts heat from outside air (even in cold temperatures) and pumps it inside your home.

• Refrigerant Process: A refrigerant absorbs heat from outside air, is compressed to increase temperature, and circulates warm air into your home.

• Works in Cold Temperatures: Even in chilly conditions (down to around -15°C), the system efficiently heats your home by extracting heat from the air outside.

Dual Functionality

• Heating & Cooling: A standout feature of reverse cycle air conditioning is its dual functionality—cool in summer and warm in winter.

• Space & Cost Efficiency: No need for separate heating and cooling systems, saving space and money in the long term.

Common Use in Australian Homes

• Widespread Use: Popular in Australian homes, especially in cities like Sydney with varying climates.

• Energy Efficient: Modern reverse cycle systems align with Australia’s push for sustainable, energy-efficient solutions.

• Year-Round Comfort: An ideal choice for homeowners seeking reliable climate control across all seasons.

‍

What Is Gas Heating?

Gas heating is another reliable and effective way to heat your home, known for quickly generating warmth. It works by burning natural gas or LPG to produce heat, which is then distributed throughout your house. Gas heating can be particularly beneficial when the goal is to quickly and efficiently heat a space.

Types of Gas Heating

1. Ducted Gas Heating

• Centralised System: Heats air in a central unit and distributes it throughout the house via ducts.

• Zoned Heating: Heat only the rooms you need, making it energy-efficient.

• Ideal for Large Homes: Perfect for larger areas or entire homes that require consistent warmth.

2. Gas Wall Heaters

• Fixed Unit: Installed on the wall, ideal for heating single rooms or smaller areas.

• Flued & Unflued Options: Flued units vent gases outside, ensuring safe operation, while unflued models are compact but require good ventilation.

• Quick & Efficient: Known for delivering fast, localised warmth in targeted areas.

3. Portable Gas Heaters  

• Flexible & Convenient: Easily moved from room to room for temporary heating.

• Unflued Units: Must ensure proper ventilation to avoid harmful gases buildup.

• Best for Smaller Spaces: Perfect for areas where permanent installation isn't feasible, providing heat when and where you need it.

Common Use of Gas Heating

Gas heating remains a popular choice across Australia, especially in regions with easy access to natural gas. It's particularly effective when you need to warm up a space quickly.

• Quick & Reliable: Ideal for providing fast warmth during cold spells, especially in Sydney's mild winters when quick temperature adjustments are needed.

• Cost-Effective: Gas heating can be more affordable, particularly if natural gas prices are lower than electricity rates.

• Economic Installation: If your home already has existing gas infrastructure, installing a gas heater is often simpler and more affordable.

‍

Cost Comparison: Installation and Maintenance

Understanding the cost implications of different heating and cooling systems is crucial when upgrading to a more efficient solution. In this section, we compare the upfront installation costs and ongoing maintenance needs of reverse cycle air conditioning and gas heating systems in Sydney.

‍

Upfront Installation Costs

Reverse Cycle Air Conditioning

Reverse cycle air conditioning systems, which offer both heating and cooling capabilities, have become increasingly popular in Sydney due to their versatility. The installation cost for these systems can vary based on several factors, including the size of the unit, the complexity of the installation, and the specific needs of the property.

1. Single-Split Systems

• Cost: AUD 1,500 – AUD 3,000.

• Ideal for: Single rooms or small apartments.

• Includes: Unit cost and professional installation.

2. Multi-Split Systems

• Cost: AUD 5,000 – AUD 9,000.

• Ideal for: Larger homes or multiple rooms.

• Includes: Multiple indoor units, installation, and system complexity.

3. Ducted Systems

• Cost: AUD 8,000 – AUD 15,000.

• Ideal for: Whole-home climate control.

• Includes: Extensive ductwork, professional installation, and home size considerations.

Gas Heating Systems

Gas heating systems, which are commonly used in Sydney homes, also come with varying installation costs based on the type and complexity of the system.

1. Wall Furnaces

• Cost: AUD 1,200 – AUD 2,500.

• Ideal for: Single-room or small area heating.

• Includes: Unit cost and professional installation.

2. Ducted Gas Heating

• Cost: AUD 3,500 – AUD 8,000.

• Ideal for: Larger homes or multiple room heating.

• Includes: Furnace, ductwork, installation, and home layout considerations.

‍

Ongoing Maintenance Needs

Reverse Cycle Air Conditioning

To ensure your system runs smoothly and efficiently, regular maintenance is key.

1. Servicing Frequency

• Recommendation: At least once a year.

• For high-use areas: Bi-annual servicing can be beneficial.

2. Cost of Servicing

• Typical Cost: AUD 150 – AUD 300.

• Factors: Complexity of system, additional services like cleaning or repairs.

3. Common Maintenance Tasks

• Cleaning/replacing filters.

• Checking for refrigerant leaks.

• Ensuring electrical connections are secure.

Gas Heating Systems

Gas heating systems also require annual servicing to maintain safety and efficiency.

1. Servicing Frequency

• Recommendation: Annually, ideally before the winter season starts.

2. Cost of Servicing

• Typical Cost: AUD 150 – AUD 250.

• Factors: System complexity and need for additional repairs.

3. Common Maintenance Tasks

• Checking flue and gas connections for leaks.

• Cleaning burners.

• Ensuring thermostat functionality.

By understanding both the installation and ongoing maintenance costs of these systems, Sydney homeowners can make a well-informed choice that balances financial considerations and home comfort.

‍

‍

Running Costs: Electricity vs. Gas Prices in Australia

When deciding whether air conditioning or gas heating is more economical, it’s essential to understand the running costs of each system. This involves comparing the cost per hour of operation, using common metrics such as cost per kilowatt-hour (kWh) for electricity and megajoules (MJ) for gas. Here’s how these costs break down in Sydney.

‍

Average Cost per Hour of Use

Electricity Costs for Air Conditioning

The cost of running an air conditioner depends on the unit size, efficiency, and local electricity rates. In Australia, electricity prices typically range from 20 to 30 cents per kWh.

• Typical Air Conditioner Usage: A medium-sized reverse cycle air conditioner might consume 2 kWh to 6 kWh per hour, depending on its size and temperature setting.

• Example Calculation: 3 kWh x $0.25 (average electricity cost) = $0.75 per hour for a medium-sized unit.

‍

Gas Costs for Heating

Gas heating costs are based on the price per megajoule (MJ) and the heater's energy consumption. In Australia, natural gas prices range from 3 to 5 cents per MJ.

• Typical Gas Heater Usage: A gas heater might consume between 20 to 40 MJ per hour.

• Example Calculation: 30 MJ x $0.04 (average gas cost) = $1.20 per hour for a typical gas heater.

From these examples, we can see that air conditioning tends to have a lower hourly running cost compared to gas heating. However, other factors can impact these costs, making it important to consider more than just these basic figures.

‍

Factors That Affect Running Costs

Insulation

• Impact on Costs: Proper insulation reduces energy consumption by keeping heat inside during winter and outside during summer, reducing the strain on both air conditioning and gas heating systems.

• Well-Insulated Homes: Require less energy to maintain the desired temperature.

• Poor Insulation: Increases energy use, as systems must work harder to compensate for heat loss or gain.

System Size and Efficiency

• Oversized or Undersized Units: A system that is too large or too small for your space will operate inefficiently, leading to higher energy consumption.

• High-Efficiency Systems: Though they may cost more upfront, they can significantly lower long-term running costs by consuming less energy while maintaining comfort.

Thermostat Settings

• Heating: Every degree above 20°C can increase energy usage by up to 10%. Set your thermostat to a moderate temperature to reduce energy consumption.

• Cooling: For cooling, setting the temperature a few degrees higher can save energy and reduce running costs.

• Energy Savings: A well-maintained and correctly set thermostat can significantly impact your monthly energy bills.

Usage Patterns

• Continuous Operation: Running systems at full capacity continuously leads to higher energy usage.

• Smart Use: By using programmable thermostats to reduce heating or cooling during non-peak hours or when rooms are unoccupied, you can substantially reduce costs.

By understanding these factors, homeowners can make more informed decisions about which system—air conditioning or gas heating—will be the most cost-effective for their needs. Adjusting settings, optimising insulation, and choosing the right system can lead to significant savings over time.

‍

Efficiency and Environmental Impact

When deciding between air conditioning and gas heating, it’s crucial to factor in both energy efficiency and environmental impact. This will help businesses in Sydney make informed decisions that support both cost-effectiveness and sustainability.

‍

Energy Efficiency Ratings

Air Conditioning Systems

• Energy Efficiency: Modern air conditioning units, especially those with inverter technology, are highly energy-efficient. They adjust their output to maintain a consistent temperature, avoiding the energy spikes that traditional systems can experience.

• Energy Rating Label: This label provides a star rating to indicate the system’s efficiency. The higher the star rating, the more energy-efficient the system is.

• Reverse Cycle Air Conditioning: These systems are capable of heating and cooling and are often more efficient than gas heating in mild climates like Sydney’s. Reverse cycle units use heat pump technology, which transfers heat rather than generating it through combustion, making them up to three times more efficient than traditional heaters.

• Ideal for Sydney: Given Sydney’s temperate climate, reverse cycle air conditioners are particularly suited for mild winters and hot summers, making them an excellent option for year-round efficiency.

Gas Heating Systems

• Instant Heat: Gas heaters are known for providing quick, intense heat, which is ideal for colder climates but less necessary in Sydney’s mild winters.

• Efficiency Variance: The efficiency of gas heating systems depends on the model and age of the unit. Modern condensing gas heaters use technology to extract additional heat from exhaust gases, improving efficiency.

• Lower Efficiency Compared to Electric Heat Pumps: Despite improvements, gas heaters generally fall short in energy efficiency when compared to modern electric heat pump systems, especially during a full heating season.

‍

Emissions and Environmental Considerations

Electricity and Solar Power

• Renewable Energy: Electricity, especially from solar power, provides significant environmental advantages. Sydney’s climate makes it an ideal location for harnessing solar energy, offering businesses the opportunity to reduce their carbon footprint.

• Minimal Direct Emissions: Air conditioning systems powered by renewable electricity produce minimal emissions compared to fossil-fuel-powered systems.

• Solar Integration: Businesses can use solar panels to power their air conditioners, further reducing their reliance on the grid and coal-fired power stations, which still make up a large portion of Australia’s electricity generation.

• Cost Savings & Incentives: Investing in solar energy not only lowers electricity bills but also opens up opportunities for government incentives and rebates, making solar a financially attractive option for businesses.

Natural Gas

• Fossil Fuel Emissions: While natural gas is considered cleaner than other fossil fuels, it still releases carbon dioxide when burned. Additionally, methane leaks during extraction and transportation are a significant concern, as methane is a potent greenhouse gas with much higher warming potential than carbon dioxide.

• Environmental Impact in Sydney: In Sydney’s mild climate, the demand for intense heating is lower, making gas heating less environmentally sustainable. Transitioning to electric heating solutions powered by renewable energy can help significantly reduce emissions.

• Long-Term Sustainability: Natural gas may be a cleaner alternative to coal, but it still contributes to global warming, especially in the long term.

For business owners aiming to optimise both operational costs and environmental footprint, air conditioning powered by renewable energy presents the more economical and sustainable choice.

‍

‍

When Each System Makes More Sense

Choosing the right heating and cooling system can impact your comfort, energy consumption, and utility bills. Understanding when air conditioning or gas heating makes more sense can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your needs.

‍

Best Option for Smaller Homes or Apartments

Air Conditioning

• Ideal for Smaller Spaces: Air conditioning is a perfect solution for smaller homes or apartments, where space and installation costs are a concern.

• Cost-Effective Installation: Split systems or ductless mini-splits are less expensive to install and don’t require extensive ductwork, making them a great choice for homes without gas lines.

• Dual Functionality: Many modern air conditioners are reverse cycle, offering both cooling and heating, which makes them highly versatile for Sydney’s mild climate.

• Compact & Adjustable: Portable or window units are compact, easy to move, and perfect for apartments or rooms where flexibility is important.

Gas Heating

• Existing Gas Connection: If your home already has natural gas lines, installing a gas heater can be a straightforward and affordable option.

• Quick Heating: Gas heaters can provide instant warmth, making them effective during particularly cold periods, even in small spaces.

‍

Best Option for Larger Homes or Colder Regions

Air Conditioning

• Efficient Cooling for Larger Homes: Air conditioning is essential for larger homes, especially in warmer Australian climates. Central air conditioning systems can handle big spaces efficiently.

• Zoning Capabilities: Modern systems allow you to zone different areas of the home, meaning you can control the temperature in each zone, saving energy and costs.

• Year-Round Comfort: In areas with long, hot summers, air conditioning is indispensable for ensuring year-round comfort.

Gas Heating

• Effective in Cold Climates: Gas heating is ideal for larger homes in colder regions of Australia, as it delivers consistent and powerful warmth.

• Cost-Effective for Cold Winters: In areas where natural gas is affordable, gas heating can be more economical than electric systems for heating large areas.

‍

Availability of Natural Gas vs. Electrical Upgrades

Natural Gas Availability

• Local Availability: If natural gas is readily available in your area, a gas heater can be an affordable and efficient choice.

• Minimal Infrastructure Costs: Homes with existing gas connections can integrate a gas heater without incurring significant installation costs.

• Low Operational Costs: In regions where natural gas is cheap, gas heating may have lower operating costs compared to electricity-powered systems.

Electrical Upgrades

• No Gas? No Problem: In areas without natural gas connections, or where electricity is more reliable or affordable, air conditioning systems are often the better option.

• Solar Energy Integration: Homes with solar panels or other renewable energy sources can significantly offset the cost of running air conditioning systems, reducing grid dependency.

• Future-Proofing: With increasing emphasis on green energy and carbon reduction, electric systems are becoming more viable as Australia transitions towards renewable energy solutions.

‍

By evaluating these factors—home size, climate, energy availability, and future needs—you can make the best choice between air conditioning and gas heating that fits both your comfort and sustainability goals.

Choosing between air conditioning and gas heating is more than just a matter of comfort—it's about making a smart investment in your home’s energy efficiency and environmental future. Whether you’re looking for year-round versatility with air conditioning or the powerful, instant warmth of gas heating, understanding your home’s needs, climate, and energy options can help you make an informed decision.

If you're ready to optimise your home's heating and cooling, consider consulting with an expert to assess your specific needs and explore the best solutions for your space. With the right system, you can enjoy greater comfort, reduced energy costs, and a more sustainable home. Take the next step today—reach out to a professional to find the perfect solution tailored to your home and start making the most of your energy choices!